Tag

Reasonableness Test

All articles tagged with #reasonableness test

"Proposed Bill Removes 'Reasonableness' Test for Politicians in First Reading"

Originally Published 2 years ago — by The Times of Israel

The first reading of a controversial bill to block judicial review over the "reasonableness" of politicians' decisions has passed in the Knesset, with a vote of 64 to 56. The bill aims to limit judicial scrutiny over politicians' decrees, completely outlawing courts from using the reasonableness test to invalidate or discuss decisions made by the cabinet and elected officials. Supporters argue that it allows elected representatives to have the final say on policy and appointments, while critics argue that it removes an important check on arbitrary decision-making. The legislation needs to pass two more readings to become law, and the coalition aims to complete the process before the Knesset breaks for the summer.

world politics benjamin-netanyahu judicial-overhaul knesset opposition politics reasonableness-test

"Israel's MKs to Vote on Controversial Bill Limiting Judicial Review of Government Decisions"

Originally Published 2 years ago — by The Times of Israel

The Knesset is set to vote on a bill that would limit judicial review of the "reasonableness" of government decisions, as part of a broader plan to overhaul Israel's judiciary. The bill, which is expected to pass its first reading, has sparked protests and criticism from opposition members and legal experts. The proposed legislation would prevent courts from using the reasonableness test to invalidate or discuss decisions made by elected officials. Critics argue that the test is a crucial safeguard against government abuse, while proponents claim it enables rule by the judiciary. The bill is seen as a precursor to a larger effort to weaken judicial checks on political power, including increasing political influence over judicial appointments.

world politics government-decisions judicial-review knesset politics protests reasonableness-test