The article critiques the subjective nature of the initial College Football Playoff rankings, highlighting reliance on 'vibes' and film evaluation over transparent metrics, raising concerns about fairness and consistency in team assessments.
The recent Supreme Court decision against racial and ethnic preferences in college admissions could lead to a more subjective and mysterious admissions process, as colleges try to comply with the law while still admitting a diverse class of students. Officials predict less emphasis on standardized metrics like test scores and more emphasis on personal qualities, such as recommendations and application essays. However, it would be challenging to eliminate any mention or suggestion of race in the admissions process. The decision may result in an immediate drop in the number of Black and Hispanic students at selective universities. Many schools have already been planning for this moment and have made moves toward a "race-neutral" admissions era, focusing on academic rigor, supporting low-income students, and expanding recruitment efforts. The decision could also lead to a reevaluation of preferences for alumni and donors.