Tag

Adversarial Collaboration

All articles tagged with #adversarial collaboration

"Debunking the Leading Theory on Consciousness: Is it Pseudoscience?"

Originally Published 2 years ago — by The Conversation

Featured image for "Debunking the Leading Theory on Consciousness: Is it Pseudoscience?"
Source: The Conversation

Over 100 consciousness researchers have accused the integrated information theory (IIT) of being pseudoscience, sparking a debate within the field. IIT, proposed by neuroscientist Giulio Tononi, aims to provide mathematical conditions for determining consciousness. Supporters of the theory argue that it expands the concept of consciousness, while critics claim that it lacks experimental support for its bold implications. An "adversarial collaboration" between IIT and the global workspace theory recently produced mixed results. The controversy highlights the challenge of studying consciousness, which involves both scientific experimentation and philosophical reflection. The debate underscores the need for a partnership between science and philosophy to unravel the mysteries of consciousness.

Unveiling the Truth: Insights into Consciousness Theories and AI Consciousness

Originally Published 2 years ago — by Quanta Magazine

Featured image for Unveiling the Truth: Insights into Consciousness Theories and AI Consciousness
Source: Quanta Magazine

An adversarial collaboration between two leading theories of consciousness, Global Neuronal Workspace Theory (GNWT) and Integrated Information Theory (IIT), resulted in mixed results and no clear winner. The experiments involved decoding brain patterns and testing different aspects of consciousness. While both theories were challenged by the results, IIT scored slightly better in the overall tally. However, the project leaders emphasized that the results confirmed some predictions of both theories while challenging them as well. The collaboration pushed theorists to make more tangible predictions and experimentalists to develop new techniques, advancing the field of consciousness research.