"2023 Fantasy Baseball Draft Prep: Challenging Consensus Rankings and Finding League-Winning Picks"

Expert Consensus Rankings (ECR) for starting pitchers in fantasy baseball are not always accurate. Dustin May, Tony Gonsolin, and Tyler Glasnow are undervalued, while Sandy Alcantara, Alek Manoah, and Chris Bassitt are overvalued. May has great stuff and is healthy, Gonsolin had a high win total despite low strikeouts, and Glasnow has elite stuff and could benefit from his injury. Alcantara's low strikeout rate and team context make him less valuable, while Manoah and Bassitt have shown decreased velocity and face tough challenges in the AL East and Toronto's new hitter-friendly park.