"Judge Stephen Murphy Faces Backlash for Biased Comment on Defendant's Appearance"

A federal appeals court panel has overturned the conviction and prison sentence of a heroin trafficker, criticizing the trial judge for making "unacceptable remarks," including stating that the defendant "looks like a criminal." The court rebuked U.S. District Judge Stephen Murphy for his conduct and ordered a new trial to be held in front of a different judge. The panel expressed concern over the racial bias implications of the judge's remark, emphasizing the importance of treating all defendants with dignity, respect, and fairness. The judge's comments were deemed incompatible with the fair administration of justice.