Controversy and Surprises in First 12-Team College Football Playoff

The College Football Playoff's first 12-team bracket has sparked debate, particularly over SMU's inclusion over Alabama. The selection committee prioritized conference championship participation, rewarding SMU despite their loss to Clemson, over Alabama's stronger schedule but inconsistent performance. The decision underscores the importance of conference titles and aims to maintain the value of championship games. The rankings also highlighted the committee's willingness to overlook weaker schedules, as seen with Texas and Penn State, while emphasizing the need for future CFP reforms.