Assessing Gabe Kapler's Impact on the Giants' 2023 Season and Future

The San Francisco Giants' disappointing 2023 season has sparked debate about whether manager Gabe Kapler should be fired. Critics argue that the team's lackluster roster is the main reason for their struggles, while others believe Kapler's managerial decisions have hindered their success. However, the article suggests that managers have less impact on in-game success over a 162-game season than commonly believed. Kapler has faced challenges with an underperforming roster, relying heavily on bullpen games, and managing player relationships. While some players have praised Kapler's positivity and support, there are concerns about his decision-making and the team's lack of entertainment value. Ultimately, the article suggests that improving the roster should be the priority, but a change in managerial approach may also be necessary to address fan dissatisfaction.