Madewell x Benjamin Talley Smith Denim Capsule Delivers a Bold Silhouette (But Not for Everyone)

The Cut Shop tests Madewell’s limited capsule with denim whisperer Benjamin Talley Smith, featuring seven non‑stretch, 100% cotton pieces handcrafted in Los Angeles. The standout is the Coolidge Low‑Rise Wide‑Leg Jean, whose ultrawide silhouette elongates the frame (tested in a 27, dark wash) but is very low‑rise and long; the Putney Mid‑Rise Straight Jean fit poorly in tester’s 27 and felt less worth the $285 price. The capsule ranges from $88 to $398 and includes a denim jacket, sweatshirts, and more. Overall, the collection is worth it for the distinctive silhouette and artisanal quality, especially the Coolidge, but sizing quirks and the high price may deter some shoppers.